The main problem with the abstinence method is that it just defines one method of contraception and it really doesn't address the underlying dangers of sex. It just says, in order to stay safe and maintain your values, don't have sex. Plain and simple. But I think for a lot of people one option is never good enough, we as humans like choice. And some people will choose not to abstain from sex. So what happens then? What happens if their parents never addressed it and their school never addressed it? Where can they turn to for reliable answers? It puts numerous questions in their minds and can really make this, already tough, time even more difficult. Kids are unaware of a lot of the dangers and a lot of ways to prevent those dangers. Where as just being straightforward about sex (the comprehensive method) answers questions and concerns and puts a lot of minds at ease when it comes to this controversial topic. If you're more informed you're more likely to make informed decisions. In fact in study, using the abstinence method has no positive affect on delaying sexual interaction. There was no difference in initiation of sex, age at initiation of sex, abstinence in the previous 12 months, number of sexual partners, or condom use during sex, than with the comprehensive method. The comprehensive method is informs, which is increasingly important with the HIV virus and other deadly STD's.
The abstinence method has a lot of proponents, mainly parents. Abstinence programs emphasize abstinence until marriage. Some allow objective discussion of the effectiveness of condoms and contraceptives without encouraging their use, others, have very strongly opposed condoms and contraceptives and exaggerated their lack of effectiveness. Still others do not even mention condoms or contraception. Abstinence education argues that the comprehensive method encourages premarital sex and activity. The abstinence only education also emphasizes that this method teaches kids about morals and the emotional toll a sexual relationship can have on you if you're not in a committed relationship (marriage).
Speaking from personal struggle, there is a major issue when it comes to the topic of sex. It's viewed as an embarrassing topic and a lot of people feel ashamed about it. Which should not be the case at all. One thing I have come to realize is that sex should be something special between two people, you shouldn't have to feel ashamed about it and you have every right to question it. It's part of being human. I think it's a major part of growing up and I hate to think that it's viewed in such a negative light. I think it's an issue that should be brought to a lot of people's attention especially with the increase of teen pregnancy and STD's. There's a lot that people are unaware of and I think becoming aware is the first step to figuring out what your values are. They should be defined by you.
I love that you say that sex is an embarrassing topic and that it shouldn't be. I completely agree. I am one that is open about most everything, and I have been as open about sex as I can be. This being said, that is not much. There is a certain stigma attached to the topic of sex, therefore attached to anyone who even thinks of talking openly about their sexuality. If you talk about sex, you are seen as a whore. Being a straight female, this is how I have always felt about it at least. This construction is something that I agree needs to be changed in order for all of these negative phenomenons to lower. Sex needs to be something discussed openly so that people, especially teenagers, are able to properly deal with their sexuality. This will prevent the danger of sex as well as the uncomfortableness of the topic.
ReplyDeleteThis is a great topic for this blog, and it's completely true. You don't learn anything about sex if you abstain from it completely; it's a valuable learning experience especially when it comes to the responsibility to seek other forms of birth control etc. And it's true, people (especially parents) feel awkward discussing it with their kids when they really shouldn't. It's important, and even a single conversation can really make a difference. Great topic!
ReplyDeleteYou raise some good points about sex education. What was most interesting to me however, was your discussion of the culture clash you experienced when you realized that the rest of society did not view sex in the same way that you were taught.
ReplyDeleteI was raised Catholic too, and grew up attending Catholic high school (where we were taught abstinence, of course). When I transferred to a public high school at the age of 15, it was definitely a shock. Learning about sex and intimacy in a Catholic school environment and then again in a public school environment was a strange experience, but a valuable one. At that time in our lives our views all mostly came down to the way we were raised and it was hard to understand where each other was coming from. As I grew older, and began discussing sex more openly I had to teach myself to "build bridges" between the Catholic upbringing I had, the beliefs I have now as an adult, and the beliefs that others have.